Refer a Friend & get £5
When you’re looking for a sustainable and healthy way to lose weight, it is only natural that you’re going to explore using shakes as a meal replacement. But are protein shakes and meal replacement shakes interchangeable?
The short answer to that question is no. However, you need to look carefully at the composition of any shakes you’re planning to incorporate into your routine to ensure they will deliver what you need from them.
The biggest difference between meal replacement shakes and protein shakes stems from their purpose.
Protein shakes are formulated to provide additional protein intake – as their name suggests. They are not designed to be a well-balanced and nutritious meal. Meal replacement shakes, on the other hand, are exactly this.
They are designed to replace a meal, which means they contain a balance of protein, carbohydrates, fats, fibre, vitamins and minerals to ensure that your body gets all the nutrients it needs, just with fewer calories.
Make sure you check what’s included in the meal replacement shakes you’re considering to ensure they have all the components of a healthy diet. We pride ourselves on providing nutritionally balanced meal replacement shakes that tick all of these boxes.
When thinking about how protein and meal replacement shakes differ, also consider when you are most likely to reach for a protein shake. Often these are a go-to after a gym session because the high protein content can support your muscles’ recovery.
In addition, when you consume enough protein consistently, whether through shakes or other dietary sources, you are more likely to see an increase in your muscle strength and power.
However, if you are aiming to lose weight, meal replacement shakes are a better option because they are formulated to help you do so while maintaining healthy levels of nutrition.
As their name suggests, meal replacement shakes are designed to be consumed instead of a meal. They are ideal if you are undertaking a calorie deficit diet as they are formulated to provide complete nutrition with fewer calories.
What’s more, they are designed to help you feel fuller for longer. This increase in satiety is one of the keys to helping you stick to whatever meal plan you are on because when you feel full, you’re less likely to be tempted to reach for snacks.
The other reason meal replacement shakes are effective for weight loss is that they are easy to make. When you are on a weight loss plan, convenience is important because any meal that takes too long to prepare can lead to you reaching for unhealthy alternatives.
How much weight you lose by using meal replacement shakes will depend on how many meals you are swapping each day, how many calories you are consuming overall and how much exercise you’re doing.
We offer a range of meal plans that work alongside our meal replacement shakes, the idea being that you lose weight in a steady, sustainable way so that it stays off. As a result, many of our plans lead to weight loss of between half a kilogram and one kilogram per week.
This is assuming that you’re using our meal replacement shakes alongside a calorie-controlled diet and are undertaking other healthy habits.
There is evidence that if you follow a weight loss plan that includes meal replacement products, you will lose more weight in the long term than if you approach the process of losing weight without also consuming meal replacements.
So, while you might initially be focusing on the amount of weight you can lose, it is actually more important to think about how you can keep any weight off for the long term, because this will have the greatest positive impact on your health.
This very much depends on how you consume your protein shakes. Because of their high protein content, they can help you to feel full for longer.
However, if you simply plan to incorporate protein shakes into your pre- or post-workout routine without making other changes to your diet and calorie consumption, protein shakes are unlikely to lead to weight loss.
That said, protein shakes can still be useful on your weight loss journey as they can support muscle recovery and help you build muscle, all of which is important for improving your metabolism.
The important point to take from all of this is that you need to think carefully about your goals before you choose a meal replacement shake or a protein shake. Work out what you want to achieve and then seek out the right products to support you on that journey.
